Friday, September 6, 2024
Home Blog Page 594

Immigrants and labor rights groups to march for unconditional amnesty

Compiled by Elisabeth Pinio

Fiona MaFiona Ma

San Francisco community leaders and Immigrant and Workers Rights groups announced a March for Unconditional Amnesty on May 1 in San Francisco. The March will take place at Mission Cultural Center at 2 p.m. Organizers invite all immigrants and San Franciscans to participate in this event.

Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has created critical circumstances for immigrants and their families as they have increased their raid and capturing operations. Families are torn apart and left impoverished and helpless, while ICE’s activities force immigrants into hiding and encourage black market immigration.

Anti-Human trafficking bill approved by Assembly Judiciary Committee

AB 1278 passed unanimously by the Assembly Judiciary Committee. AB 1278, drafted by Assemblywoman Fiona Ma (D-San Francisco), will increase maximum penalties for human trafficking offenses, prohibit contracts allowing deductions from a person’s wages for their transport into the United States, and provide more power to district attorneys for the prosecution of those trafficking minors. Additionally, the bill will allow for a single jurisdiction forprosecution of traffickers operating in more than one country.

“Human trafficking is modern day slavery,” said Assemblywoman Ma in a statement.” She also authored legislation to enforce penalties on message parlors serving as fronts for human trafficking in San Francisco.

City College alumna to speak at graduation

Desirree Abshire, Trustee of the Yosemite Community College District, will speak at the 2007 Commencement Exercises of City College of San Francisco as an alumna. A native San Franciscan, and daughter of a Nicaraguan immigrant, Abshire utilized student services and opportunities offered at City College to gain valuable experience in public advocacy and politics. She graduated from UC Berkeley in 2004, with a degree in Political Science. She currently serves as the Project Manager for a public relations firm focused on social, educational, and governmental outreach.

Abshire’s position on the Yosemite Community College Board enables her to extend her efforts to college campuses in Sonora and Modesto. She was elected as the youngest member and the first Latina to represent the Area 2 district.

Governor Schwarzenegger supports gang legislation

U.S. Senator Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) has announced Governer Schwarzenegger’s endorsement of comprehensive gang legislation she introduced in the Senate on January 31, 2007. The five-year legislation affords over $1 billion in gang prevention, intervention, and law enforcement programs. The legislation also increases federal punishment to discourage and penalize gang members, by making illegal participation in street gangs a new federal crime.

“Gang violence is a problem in communities all over California. We need to have a coordinated approach among federal, state and local governments to work together and eliminate this problem,” Governor Schwarzenegger said in his letter of support.

Burlngame School District launches Spanish Immersion Language

The Burlingame School District will introduce a Spanish language immersion program to Kindergarten and First Graders at McKinley Elementary School, starting in the 2007/2008 school year.

Students with a bilingual education have an advantage over those without. “Studies show that graduates of language immersion programs demonstrate a cognitive edge, increased self-esteem, higher academic achievement and ultimately promote positive cultural and global social awareness,” said Paula Valerio, Principal of McKinley Elementary School.

The district is currently seeking two qualified teachers to begin the 2007/2008 school year. To apply, visit http://www.bsd.k12.ca.us/immersion.htm.

­

Following Maggie the leader

by Marisella Veiga

Maggie RivasMaggie Rivas

Fifty-one-year-old Maggie Rivas Rodríguez seems comfortable at the helm of an elite group of Latino leaders she has rallied in the spreading nationwide protest against Ken Burns’ documentary on World War II. The television series is scheduled to air on PBS during Hispanic Heritage month this September.

While African-American and Japanese-American contributions are portrayed alongside whites in the 14-hour, seven-part series “The War,” Burns has totally neglected the Hispanic role. As many as half a million Latinos and Latinas, including Maggie’s father, served in the U.S. military during that conflict

The historical oversight and Burns’ refusal to re-edit his series doesn’t sit well with Rivas Rodriguez. Her life experience has committed her to build a Hispanic World War II archive. Her vow has not fallen prey to the discouragement or disenchantment that tripped many Latinas in her youth. Maggie’s parents taught her early to stand up for her heritage and her beliefs.

Rivas Rodríguez describes Ramón Martín Rivas and Henrietta López Rivas as “incredibly cool” parents. The couple raised six girls and one boy. Maggie was number five. Her father, she says, was a big women’s libber.

“To their credit, my parents supported education all the way, even though it was not their world,” she says.

They encouraged Maggie’s move from their hometown of Devine, Texas, a community of 3,500, to Austin, the state capital 113 miles away, to pursue a bachelor’s degree at the University of Texas.

On a campus bulletin board she saw an ad calling for a radio program host. She answered it and at one point found herself hosting three programs simultaneously. She loved writing, so she began reporting for the campus newspaper as well. In 1977, she went on to pick up a master’s degree from New York’s Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism.

Maggie was a young reporter working on an article for the Dallas Morning News when she first noticed the void of information available about Latinos and Latinas in WWII.

She was among advocates who in 1982 created the National Association of Hispanic Journalists, winning election to its board. Frustrated by the industry’s failure to encourage Hispanic students to explore journalism careers, she inaugurated and developed such NAHJ projects as high school essay contests, which spread to 14 cities at their peak, and student-written newspapers providing daily coverage at national journalism conventions. The American Society of Newspapers Editors is one of several organizations that adopted her concept. It continues to use it as a tool to motivate and train Hispanic and other college journalism students

A major change occurred in Maggie’s life 13 years ago. At age 38, she married Gil Rodríguez, a public school teacher she describes as a “full partner.” She became pregnant and took a year off from reporting. Searching for ways to balance career and new family, she accepted a journalist-in-residence position at the University of Texas, El Paso.

Teaching agreed with her. Soon, with a second child due, she followed her instincts and applied for a Freedom Forum doctoral fellowship. Next stop: Chapel Hill, N.C., where she earned a PhD in 1998 from the University of North Carolina.

That accomplished, the Rivas Rodríguez family — mom, dad and two growing sons — returned to Texas where Maggie joined the journalism faculty at UT Austin.

There she established the U.S. Latino and Latina WWII Oral History Project. She and her staff have filmed and written some 550 histories, some posthumous, of those who served,

She edited two books on the subject that she first encountered as a young reporter: “Mexican Americans and World War II “(2005) and “A Legacy Greater Than Words: Stories of U.S. Latinos and Latinas of the WWII Generation” (2006).

Convinced that their contributions deserve a prominent place in the saga of this nation’s vigorous responses to fascism, communism and other external threats, she has offered to share her resource materials with PBS.

“We should never have to forsake who we are in order to succeed,” Rivas Rodriguez says, repeating wisdom she learned from her parents.

If Burns and the network continue to deny the Latino community full representation in their World War II history, it will have to contend with a formidable Latina foe whose strength belies her five-foot stature.

(Marisella Veiga, .of St Augustine, Fla., is a contributing columnist with Hispanic Link News Service. She may be reached by e-mail at mveiga@bellsouth.net). © 2007

August is time out for an immigration reform pasage

by Marvin J. Ramírez

From The Editor Marvin J. RamírezFrom The Editor Marvin J. Ramírez

In a statement of Joe García, director of the New Democratic Network (NDN) this month, he emphasized that one item, the immigration issue, is an area on which the President, Senator McCain, Harry Reid, Nancy Pelosi, the Catholic Church, the Chamber of Commerce, numerous labor unions and many other grassroots groups were able to find common cause and work together: the McCain- Kennedy approach to comprehensive immigration reform that passed the Senate with broad bipartisan support in 2006.

This agreement, however, has not been able to survive, as many other proposals have been drafted by interest groups, so confusing to advocates and the immigrant communities, as they leave millions in limbo.

“Floating a brand new approach to immigration reform, the President and his Party have stepped backward and devised a new path that will do much more to please their partisans than solve this important problem,” said García.

He asked that President Bush acts thinking in a comprehensive solution to the immigration issue, and not to follow the lead of his party.

“The President needs to publicly distance himself from the plan being floated by Senate Republican leaders, and say right now that he intends to pick up where we left off in 2006 – with the McCain-Kennedy approach that has already passed the Republican-controlled Senate,” García said.

This inaction by our legislators shows the incompetence of our Congress, and how faithful they are to interest groups who want to keep one way or another, an underground workforce, without rights and state supervision of their employers. It’s basically a form of slavery, as an African-North American police cadet commented while I spoke at the San Francisco Police Academy three weeks ago, to address the future officers.

“Anything less will show that the President, despite his passionate rhetoric today, is simply not serious about passing comprehensive immigration reform this year,” adds García.

The new and flawed Republican approach being floated, said García, will unravel this coalition, and deal a severe blow to those hoping to pass comprehensive immigration reform this year.

It’s obvious that the President is positive and hopeful that immigration reform has to be comprehensive, wrote Janet Munguía, president and CEO of the National Council of La Raza.

“But it’s time that the President starts delivering to make it happen…. Yet we must also keep in mind that the window of opportunity is fast closing.

And for this to happen, every interested party to the immigration issue must agree that Congress must pass the immigration reform legislation before August recess.

 

­

“I promise to be there,” the Mayor said, contrary to his absence in last year’s pro-immigrant marches

by Marvin J. Ramírez

Sanctuary: the theme of the day Members of the community listen to San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom: , promising to strengthen the city's Sanctuary Ordenance and to participate in May 1 pro-immmigrant march. The event was held at St. Peter's Church on April 22.  ( PHOTOS BY MARVIN J. RAMIREZ )Sanctuary: the theme of the day Members of the community listen to San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom, promising to strengthen the city’s Sanctuary Ordenance and to participate in May 1 pro-immmigrant march. The event was held at St. Peter’s Church on April 22. ( PHOTOS BY MARVIN J. RAMIREZ )

Last year, millions of people participated in two historical immigrant marches nationwide, demanding amnesty for millions of undocumented people living in the shadows. Meanwhile, Mayor Gavin Newsom was busy with other commitments, which cast doubts of his support for the undocumented plight.

While a new march on May 1st is being organized in most parts of the country, promising to be the biggest ever, Newsom said “I promise” to participate this time, during a townhall meeting at St. Peter’s Church on Sunday. The event, which attracted approximately 350 people, including Assemblyman Mark Leno and State Sen. Carol Migden, was organized by the San Francisco Organizing Project.

Newsom’s statement comes after a series of recent immigration raids in the Bay Area and pressure from immigrants and human rights advocates who have criticized him for not attending the previous marches. He pledged that San Francisco will remain a so-called “sanctuary city.”

The designation has no legal meaning, but Newsom promised that no city employee would assist in the raids.

The Board of Supervisors first declared San Francisco a sanctuary city in 1989. However, SFPD still confiscates the vehicles of undocumented people when they are stopped for minor traffic offenses, creating big business for the city and the towing companies.

Members of the new San Francisco Organization Project: , during an event on the S.F. Sancturary, with Mayor Gavin Newsom, State Sen. Carol Midgen, and Assemblymember Mark Leno at St. Peter's Church.Members of the new San Francisco Organization Project, during an event on the S.F. Sancturary, with Mayor Gavin Newsom, State Sen. Carol Midgen, and Assemblymember Mark Leno at St. Peter’s Church.

On Friday, during an immigration raid, 13 foreign nationals were arrested without work permits at an Oakland manufacturing company. These continued ICE actions are creating panic of limitless proportions within the immigrant communities, and are imprisoning entire families inside their own homes.

“And there are mothers who not only are afraid to take their children to school, but to the park,” said Deacon Nate Bacon.

“I will not allow any of my department heads or anyone associated with this city to cooperate in any way, shape or form with these raids,” Newsom declared. “We are a sanctuary city, make no mistake about it.”

Sen. Migden promised to take action calling on the ICE to respect the immigrant communities. They should know “that they can’t treat our neighbors so savagely” while encouraging the members of the SF Organizing Project to help the Latinos in El Canal, Marin County – her district – organize the way they are doing it in San Francisco.

The mayor also answered questions on the day laborers issue, which has become a hot item for advocates, after the city has moved to select the old Home Depot building on Bayshore Blvd. as the new day laborers’ building, “without consulting the day laborers.” Currently, the Day Labor Program’s office is located on César Chávez St., half a block from Mission St.

The mayor denied the charge, saying that the Bayshore site will be fit to accommodate the laborers, and denied that SFPD will start ticketing those who continue soliciting employment on César Chávez St.

“It’s not about changing what there is already,” he said, “rather to better what there is,” while promising to work with them.

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials have continued to conduct raids across the country, including arrests in San Rafael, Oakland, Richmond, San Pablo, Santa Clara and other cities across the Bay area, since May of 2006.

Immigration officials have said they are executing arrest warrants for immigrants who had committed crimes or were in the country illegally and had ignored final deportation orders.

Officials added that in the course of serving deportation warrants, other people suspected of being illegal immigrants were questioned and then arrested. However, of at least 65 Main County residents that were arrested in March, just five have been ordered deported.

In March, San Rafael Mayor, Al Boro, called on California U.S. Senators Barbara Boxer and Dianne Feinstein to persuade the immigration agency to change how it is enforcing immigration law because he believed children were the ones being hurt.

Marches and rallies are planned in many cities over the coming weeks – including

Redwood City, San Francisco, Oakland, San Jose and Sacramento – to name a few.

Newsom, Migden and Leno all vowed to work with other cities and legislators to put a stop to what they cited as blatant intimidation of immigrants.

“Our action is to stand strong in opposition to these raids… to make sure that we are not contributing in any way, shape or form,” Newsom said. “Even legal immigrants are fearful. This just sends a chill to a lot of people.”

 

­­

Uribe tries to defend himself

by the El Reportero wire services

Álvaro UribeÁlvaro Uribe

COLOMBIA: On 19 April President Alvaro Uribe acknowledged on national TV that Colombia’s standing in the international community was being affected by the wave of accusations against him and his family.

At present the president’s reputation lies in the hands of two men: Jorge Noguera, the former head of the Colombian intelligence services (DAS), and Gustavo Petro, the leftwing senator whose testimony has played an important part in revealing the government’s links with paramilitaries.

If Petro can provide more evidence for his accusations against Uribe, the president’s position could become untenable. If Noguera, who stands accused of deleting drug traffickers’ records from the DAS’s database, is found guilty, Uribe says he will apologize to the nation. It is difficult to see how his political stock, certainly internationally, could recover from such a blow.

Debate continues over biofuels

In the first article attributed to Fidel Castro since he stood down from the presidency at the end of July last year, the Cuban leader argued billions would die of starvation as a result of the increased production of biofuels.

This followed Venezuela’s President Hugo Chávez own attack on the use of food stuffs for fuel. Given that as late as 28 February Cuba and Venezuela had signed a joint agreement to build 11 ethanol plants on the Caribbean island, the change in policy was swift, seemingly prompted by U.S. President George W. Bush’s signing of a biofuel agreement with Brazil’s President Lula da Silva.

Other related story – Energy summit was stage for oblique regional leadership contest

South America’s first energy summit was expected by many to be the stage for a confrontation between Venezuela and Brazil over the latter’s ethanol deal with the US. Condemned by both Caracas and Havana as a scheme likely to divert foodstuffs away from the world’s hungry masses, the summit was seen as an opportunity for aspirants to regional leadership to gain ground. As it turned out, Venezuela backtracked on the ethanol issue, but maneuvered frantically to win on other issues.

Nicaragua wants ‘freedom’ from IMF in five years

MANAGUA – Although it will shortly seek a new loan agreement with the organization, President Daniel Ortega said that his country will freeitself from International Monetary Fund.

“Within five years Nicaragua will be free from the fund,” said Ortega, a former Marxist cold-war rebel leader who regained power after elections last year.

Starting April 30, the impoverished Central American nation will seek to extend its loan program with the IMF at a meeting in Managua. Ortega has vowed to work with business leaders and multilateral lenders.

But like his mentor, leftist Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez, Ortega is often deeply critical of the fund, which many in Latin America accuse of ignore the needs of the poor.

“It is a blessing to be free of the fund, and for the fund it will be a relief to rid itself of a government that defends the interests of the poor,” Ortega said.

Nicaragua’s previous $140 million IMF program expired on Dec. 12, a month before Ortega took office for the second time.

White house plan meets business needs, but fails on human needs

by David Bacon

­New America Media­

Luis GutiérrezLuis Gutiérrez

For the last several months, agents of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) have carried out well-publicized immigration raids in factories, meatpacking plants, janitorial services and other workplaces employing immigrants. ICE calls the workers criminals because immigration law forbids employers to hire them.

But while workers get deported and often must leave their children with relatives or even strangers, don’t expect to see their employers go to jail.

Further, ICE won’t and can’t, deport all 12 million undocumented workers in the country. This would quickly halt many industries.

Instead, these raids have a political purpose.

Last fall, after agents raided Swift 8 Co. meatpacking plants, Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff told the media the deportations would show Congress the need for “stronger border security, effective interior enforcement and a temporary-worker program.” Bush wants, he said, “a program that would allow businesses that need foreign workers, because they can’t otherwise satisfy their labor needs, to be able to get those workers in a regulated program.”

In his recent visit to Mexico, President Bush again proposed new guest worker programs. He proposed to allow corporations and contractors to recruit hundreds of thousands of workers a year outside of the U.S., and put them to work here on temporary, employment-based visas.

A few weeks ago, Reps. Luis Gutiérrez (D111.) and Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.) introduced a bill into Congress which would set up the kind of guest worker program the president called for. Corporations could bring in 400,000 guest workers annually, while the kind of sanctions that have led to the wave of workplace raids would be put on steroids.

Then last week, the administration and Republican Senator John Cornyn proposed to eliminate all family-based immigration visas, and allow people to come to the U.S. only as a result of recruitment by corporate employers.

All immigrants would become guest workers.

Labor schemes like this have a long history. From 1942 to 1964 the bracero program recruited temporary immigrants, who were exploited, cheated, and deported if they tried to go on strike. Growers pitted them against workers already in the country to drive down wages.

Cesar Chávez and other Latino leaders campaigned to get the program repealed.

Advocates of today’s programs avoid the bitter “bracero” label, and call them “guest worker” “essential worker” or Just “new worker” schemes. You can’t clean up an unpleasant reality, however, by renaming it.

Guest worker programs are low-wage schemes, intended to supply plentiful labor to corporate employers, at a price they want to pay.

Companies don’t recruit guest workers so they can pay them more, but to pay them less. According to Rob Rosado, director of legislative affairs for the American Meat Institute, meatpackers want a guest worker program’ but not a basic wage guarantee for those workers.

“We don’t want the government setting wages,’’ he says. “The market determines wages.’’

The Southern Poverty Law Center’s recent report, Close to Slavery, shows that current guest worker programs allow labor contractors to maintain blacklists of workers who work slowly or demand their rights. Public interest lawyers spend years in court, trying just to get back wages for cheated immigrants.

Meanwhile, the Department of Labor almost never decertifies contractors who abuse workers.

The AFL-CIO opposes guest worker programs, and says immigrants should be given permanent residence visas, so they have labor rights and can become normal members of the communities they live in. Since 1999’ the AFL-CIO has called for legalization of the 12 million people living in the U.S. without documents. Most unions oppose employer sanctions and the recent immigration raids’ because they’re often used to threaten and punish workers when they speak out for better wages and conditions.

Today over 180 million people in the world already live outside the countries where they were born.

In the countries that are the main sources of migration to the U.S., trade agreements like NAFTA and market-based economic reforms, have uprooted hundreds of thousands of farmers and workers’ leaving them little option other that coming north.

A rational immigration policy should end trade and investment policies abroad that produce poverty and displace people. In the U.S.’ immigration policy should emphasize rights and equality, and protect all families and communities of immigrants and native-born alike.

Using immigration raids instead as a pressure tactic to get Congress to approve guest worker programs is not a legitimate use of enforcement. It undermines the family and community values for which this country stands.

Hispanic Link.

Berkeley Public Library honors César Chávez legacy

­by Desirée Aquino

Beginning March 21, the Berkeley Public Library will host a poster exhibition related to the Commemorative Period each year that honors the legacy of César Chavez. The display is in the flat display cases on the second floor of the Central Library at 2090 Kittredge St. at Shattuck in downtown. The exhibit runs to April 23.

Two programs are also planned. A multimedia program with the short video, No Grapes, will be shown, along with a demonstration Eventsof online resources to learn more about Chavez. The program is on Tuesday, March 20 from 6:30-7:30 p.m. in the third floor community room. On March 24 from 2-2:30 p.m. a training session for online resources will be held in the third floor electronic classroom. Attendees will have hands-on computer guidance. For more information, call (510) 981-6107 or go to: www.berkeleypubliclibrary.org.

SF forum on rights of student journalists

San Francisco City College Press Club and the Department of Journalism host, “In Defense of the Student Press,” a panel to discuss student journalists rights and resources to challenge threats to a free campus press. The panel includes a student editor, a campus adviser and legal experts. The forum will be followed by a Q&A session and a reception.

This event is open to the public and will be held March 28 from 3-5:30 p.m. in Room 304 of the Rosenberg Library at City College of San Francisco, 50 Phelan Ave. For more information, call at (415) 239-3446.

La Peña hosts concert of original and traditional Latin American songs

As part of its Latin American music festival, La Peña Cultural Center presents renowned bolero singer Carmen Prieto with a special appearance by Lichi Fuentes. The bolero is a slow Latin American romantic dance and rhythm, which originated as one of two forms of Cuban rumba.

Prieto is described as the “Queen of Bolero.” Lichi Fuentes is a multi-instrumentalist and musical director of La Peña’s Community Chorus. The concert is Friday, March 30 at 8 p.m. at the Cultural Center, 3105 Shattuck Ave. in Berkeley.

Tickets are $15 in advance or $18 at the door. For more information, call (510) 849-2568 or go to: www.lapena.org.

Free workshops for economically disadvantaged SF contractors

To help financially disadvantaged businesses increase their ability to compete effectively for City contracts, the City of San Francisco is hosting “Become A Certified Firm” Workshops to offer technical assistance on completing the Certification application, documentation and site visit requirements, and information on upcoming contracting opportunities. Each year, the City and County of San Francisco awards over $710 million in contracts.

The Workshops will take place the third Thursday of every month beginning April 19, with revolving sessions on “How to Bid on City Contracts” and “Become A Certified Firm.” The workshops will be held from 10 a.m. to noon at 25 Van Ness Ave., Suite 800 in San Francisco. To register for any of the workshops, call (415) 252-2537 or e-mail:maria.cordero@sfgov.org.

S.F. will double police presence in housing authority sites

by Desirée Aquino

San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom ann­ounced on March 6 the city’s intentions to double the number of housing authority sites that receive community policing patrols. He also introduced three criminal justice measures to reduce crime and violence including enforcement of federal trespassing on housing authority property, social services and an advisory committee for housing authority sites.

In addition to Sunnydale, Alice Griffith, Hunters View and Potrero, housing authority sites Yerba Buena Plaza East, Hayes Valley North and South and Alemany will see community policing beat patrols.

First Marin-based Women’s Initiative for Self Employment class graduates

Twelve women enrolled in the first Marin-based WISE class will be honored by Congresswoman Lynn Woolsey on March 16. The event will be emceed by Marisol Muñoz-Kiehne, Ph.D. Dr. Muñoz-Kiehne was named one of the “MostInfluential Hispanics in the San Francisco Bay Area” in 2006. Congresswoman Woolsey is the first former welfare mother to serve in Congress.

Women’s Initiative for Self Employment assists high-potential low-income women who dream of business ownership. Through an intensive 20-session program — in English or Spanish — women are enabled to start, or expand their business.

San Mateo County surveying needs for seniors

San Mateo County is launching a study to help predict future characteristics and needs for adults over 60 years of age in the year 2020 and beyond. “Aging 2020” will develop a forecasting model and initial projections using existing data sources, focus groups and a county-wide household survey.

A survey firm will be calling approximately 850 randomly selected households and asking residents to spend 25 minutes completing the survey. San Mateo County’s fastest growing age group is seniors, with the fastest growing segment of the aging population among those over 85. The project is sponsored by the Health Department in collaboration with the Department of Housing, SamTrans and the San Mateo Medical Center.

Californians make up more than 10 percent of unclaimed IRS refunds

The Internal Revenue Service has unclaimed refunds totaling over $2.2 billion for 1.8 people who did not file a 2003 federal income tax return. To collect the money, a 2003 return must be filed with an IRS office by Tuesday, April 17, 2007.

California makes up more than 10 percent of the total, more than any other state. About 200,000 California taxpayers have over $236.3 million in unclaimed refunds outstanding. The IRS provides taxpayers with a three-year window for claiming a refund in cases where a return was not filed.

Immigrant crime and the fear-feeding frenzy

by José de la Isla

HOUSTON – Tell me straight. Do you think crime by immigrants is getting out of control? Has local media been carrying those stories? Do you think it’s worse now than before? Do you think the police need more legal tools to get control?

If so, there’s something you should know.

Another lengthy academic study has just come out maintaining that immigrants are far less inclined to be bad guys than our native sons. It’s the natives who grow up to become criminals.

The researchers, Dr. Ruben Rumbaut of University of California at Irvine and Dr. Walter A. Ewing, of the Immigration Policy Center, which published the study, found that between 1994 and 2000 criminal incarceration rates among immigrants were amazingly low. In that period, as the U.S. undocumented population doubled to 12 million, violent crime declined 34.2 percent and property crime dropped 26.4 percent.

Crime was low in all major categories when comparing immigrants and the native population. Among men 18 to 39 years, who mainly comprise this country’s prison inhabitants. Immigrants from Mexico were eight times less likely to be incarcerated than their U.S. counterparts. Foreign-born Salvadorans and Guatemalans had a rate six times lower than their counterpart cousins.

In a startling observation, IPC director Benjamin Johnson admitted the report implied, “At some point in the political process, the facts don’t matter… (Immigration policy issues) become about sound bites and not about data.”

That is probably why the public will discount IPC’s “The Myth of Immigrant Criminality and the Paradox of Assimilation,” the study released Feb. 26.

For more than a century, reports like this one have been saying the same thing. The Industrial Commission of 1901, the (Dillingham) Immigration Commission of 1911, and the National Commission on Law Observance and Enforcement of 1931 all found lower levels of criminal involvement among the foreign-born. The historical record is consistent.

What does this report tell us that we didn’t already know? Nothing. The more intriguing issue is, why isn’t a large noisy part of the public willing to believe it?

The report’s authors dispassionately reason that because many immigrants enter the country by overstaying visas and through unauthorized channels, their status “is framed as an assault against the ‘rule of law.’”

Rumbaut says the erroneous popular myth of immigrant criminality is fed by media anecdotes. Sensationalistic stories aid and abet an erroneous public perception.

Harvard researcher Robert Sampson, participating in a briefing on the report, calls mistaken public attitudes about immigrants and higher-crime rates a “red meat” issue used by politicians. “Being tough on crime is very popular.” In fact, the U.S., with decreasing crime, has one of the highest incarceration rates in the world. “There’s a huge disconnect,” he said.

I asked Sampson whether the findings are really not a reflection on how U.S. society assimilates information. His response: “I think that is part of our message. The data have been out here for a while but they continue to be interpreted in a particular way.”

Rumbaut says there “is something almost in the DNA of American society, this fear that strangers coming from strange places undermine the welfare of the natives.”

Mark Twain’s wry wit comes to mind: ”There are lies, damn lies, and statistics.” But if the statistics have been telling the truth all along, public opinion that believes the contrary must fall in the categories of “lies and damn lies.”

[José de la Isla, author of “The Rise of Hispanic Political Power” (Archer Books, 2003) writes a weekly commentary for Hispanic Link News Service. E-mail joseisla3@yahoo.com]. © 2007

The city should extend its sanctuary law to the cars of the undocumented

­by Marvin J. Ramírez

From The Editor ­by Marvin J. RamírezFrom The Editor ­by Marvin J. Ramírez

For nine consecutive years, Sen. Gil Cedillo D-Los Angeles, has introduced legislation to allow undocumented immigrants to drive legally.

And on the same day in January law enforcement officials were meeting in Sacramento to discuss, among other issues, federal and state court rulings restricting authority of law enforcement officers to seize vehicles, as described in a Contra Costa Times article.

Although decisions by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeal in San Francisco and the California Court of Appeal did not specifically deal with illegal immigration, in many communities the majority of cars impounded belong to unlicensed drivers in the country illegally, cites the article.

The issue highlighted the fact that most impounded cars belong to undocumented immigrants in many communities, prompting law enforcement agencies to reevaluate their impounding policies. San Francisco is no different.

According to the news report, ‘the California Police Chiefs Association has told its members it is illegal to impound vehicles of people whose only violation is driving without a license when the vehicle does not create a traffic hazard.’ But in the city, the San Francisco Police Chief continues allowing its officers to take the cars of undocumented immigrants.

And after consulting with county attorneys, the Sonoma County Sheriff’s Department became one of the first jurisdictions in the state to follow the legal advice. I don’t know where San Francisco has been when these other communities are taking the lead to protect immigrants without green card.

“This isn’t an immigration or racial issue,” Sheriff Bill Cogbill said in the Times’ news report. “But the majority of people who get their cars towed (in Sonoma County) are illegal immigrants because they can’t get a driver’s license.” – Huhh, the city by the Bay is getting lots of dollars, taking advantage of that handicap.

I question this: If San Francisco is challenging federal law by enacting ordinances that protect immigrants from federal raids (ICE) from deportation, why can’t the same city ordinance extend its sanctuary protection to their private property?

One thing the City can do, is to temporarily suspend any enforcement of state law that mandates the impounding of the vehicle for driving without a license after presenting a Consular I.D. or Matrícula Consular for identification purposes, and to require them to pass a driving test at an accredited driving/traffic schools, after paying a fee. Then the City would provide them with a driving permit, valid until the U.S. Congress passes a comprehensive immigration bill.

The City will receive a fee, like the one they collect from street vendors to work independently, even though they lack a work permit in the U.S. The fee will partially pay for this program, created for undocumented immigrants. Then we can  say that San Francisco is truly a Sanctuary City. (The Contra Costa Times contributed to this article.)